YOUR QUESTIONS ANSWERED: F.A.Q. 8

 

 

 

YOGA AND PSYCHOLOGY

QUESTION: In what way is Western Psychology related to Yoga?

ANSWER: This is an interesting yet highly complex topic that requires not only a thorough understanding of Psychology but also considerable knowledge of European history. Before embarking on a more detailed discussion, a clear definition of the term Psychology will go a long way in elucidating the issue. In conventional language, Psychology is held to be the study (Logia) of the mind (Psyche) and mental processes. In our view, this definition is unsatisfactory for a number of reasons, only two of which need to concern us here.

First, the mind, that is, the faculty of thinking, feeling and perceiving, has no independent existence of its own, being in fact a function of the Soul. Any systematic study of the mind that excludes the Soul is necessarily incomplete, potentially misleading and hence fundamentally flawed.

The fact is that the Greek word Psyche which forms the basis of the term Psychology, means not only mind but also Soul. The Soul is the conscious entity at the heart of our being. It is that part of us which provides us with awareness and understanding and continues to exist even after the death of the physical body. Since the original founders of Psychology accepted the reality of the Soul as defined above, the original and true Psychology is, by definition, that branch of knowledge which concerns itself with the Soul and its mental functions. After all, just as it is meaningless to analyse the movements of a motor car or any other vehicle without reference to its driver, the mind cannot be properly known or understood so long as one remains incognizant of the Soul. On the other hand, if the Soul is known, the mind is necessarily also known.

Second, as Psychology has a practical application based on knowledge of the Soul (and its mental functions) and not just on the study thereof, it may be appropriately termed Science. It follows from this, that Psychology properly speaking is the Science of the conscious Soul - or Science of Consciousness as Professor Jung put it. It is the knowledge of how consciousness experiences, and interacts with, the World and, in the final analysis, how consciousness experiences and relates to itself: in other words, Self-Knowledge or Self-Realisation which, as we know, is the very essence of Yoga.

The clarification of this point is particularly important in view of the fact that it has been a source of confusion and a major obstacle in the understanding of both Yoga and Psychology even among Indian scholars with modern academic training. The fact is that any form of Psychology that is not based on knowledge of the conscious Soul (or consciousness) is not proper Psychology. Thus the correct Hindi term for true Psychology should be not Mano-Vijnana (Mind-Knowledge) but Atma-Jnana (Soul-Knowledge) which is a long-established synonym for Yoga. Likewise, genuine Yogis who are traditionally known by the various synonymous appellations of Atma-Vid, Atma-Jnani (Knowers of the Soul), or Jnaneshvara (Masters of Spiritual Knowledge), are the original and true Psychologists and Doctors of the Soul.

While this may come as a shock to those familiar exclusively with the conventional concept of Psychology, from a Yogic perspective Yoga and Psychology are essentially identical. This fact will become evident if we briefly examine the historical connections between the two systems.

Western Psychology as we know it today, has its origins in the natural reaction to the growing materialism of the 18th and 19th centuries that followed a long millennium of religious authoritarianism and oppression. Deprived of a Spiritual experience of life, the human heart was longing for an alternative to the theology-centred dogma of the Christian Church on one hand and the Soul-less theories of Science, on the other.

It is important to remember that it all had started with the rise of Bible-based faiths during the Middle Ages (known as the Dark Ages of human history) in particular the period beginning with the disintegration of the Roman Empire in the 4th century up to the 8th century when Europe was unnecessarily - and often forcibly - converted to Christianity while much of Asia fell under Muslim military occupation. This in itself created an artificial division between the two continents which for millennia had formed a geographical, cultural and Spiritual unity.

Moreover, through their Middle-East-oriented worldview, the new religions aimed to eliminate all reference to people's Ancestral Spirituality. Nations which had been at home in Europe from earliest prehistory were suddenly requested to regard themselves as descendants of Abraham and Moses - no less - and to adopt the State-sponsored beliefs and practices of some obscure Middle-Eastern sect with a disturbing ambition for World domination. To make matters worse, all aspects of everyday life were controlled to the smallest detail by the religious authorities who expected people to dedicate their lives exclusively to the edification of the Church.

Needless to say, this absurd disregard of historical, Spiritual and psychological realities, which was contrary to the natural instincts of the people, could hardly be conducive to mental and emotional health. It was in fact directly responsible for an unprecedented rise in cases of psychological disorder among large sections of the population. The infamous witch-hunts and other atrocities committed in the name of religion during this time, are perhaps the best-known illustration of the collective insanity that had descended upon most Western countries.

To eliminate any misunderstanding, we may note here that Yoga does not condemn any religion, one of The Yoga Order's principal functions being to encourage mutual understanding and co-operation between all religious denominations. However, the truth is that conventional religion in general and individual religions - for example, Christianity - in particular, do not always work for everybody. In such cases, a dissatisfied person has every legal, moral and Spiritual right to seek fulfilment in alternative forms of Spirituality. This is a very important fact that no rational being can ignore or deny. Unlike conventional religion which has time and again become involved in acts of violence such as military invasions, forced conversions and other genocidal activities, Yoga regards the World as a Community of Free Souls and we strongly reject any attempt to impose a religious belief on intelligent beings as a serious transgression against the Spiritual Laws of the Universe.

As it happens, the light of Christianity did not bring the Illumination the Western Soul had been longing for. On the contrary, what had started as a supposed religion of brotherhood and love, soon became an instrument of social, political and religious oppression. It may be worthy of note in this context that not only have 2,000 years of Christianity produced remarkably few cases of what could qualify as Enlightenment from a Yogic point of view, but those who in the past did exhibit a degree of Spiritual Realisation, such as Meister Eckhart, St. John of the Cross or Jacob Boehme, far from receiving due recognition and support, were typically met by the Church authorities with a mixture of embarrassment and suspicion that fully exposed the system's Spiritual inadequacy. In consequence, people began to search for light elsewhere. One of the first rays of hope was that of emergent Science. Yet although the excesses of state-imposed religion were tempered somewhat by a more rational approach to life pioneered by the votaries of Science, the scientific worldview proved equally unable to satisfy the needs of the Soul. Even worse, the science-based Industrial Revolution of the late 18th and early 19th centuries was to turn millions of people into victims of systematic exploitation by the powerful few.

Thus it was against this background of general de-Spiritualisation and de-humanisation of life, that by the 19th century a new field of knowledge dawned on the academic horizon of Europe: Psychology. The way towards the reinstating of man at the centre of scholarly interest had already been paved by Anthropology, the Science of Man, through its two branches, Anatomy and Physiology, which studied the functions of the physical body. As a Spiritual complementary to this, Psychology concerned itself with the Knowledge of the Soul or Psyche, placing it at the centre of scientific investigation. There can be no doubt, therefore, that true Psychology was a Spiritual as well as scientific endeavour from the very beginning.

The result of centuries of Church-imposed suppression had been to drive people's natural Spiritual instincts into the recesses of their subconscious mind, creating a chronic psychological split in many individuals. A healing process was only possible by consciously reversing the situation. What European man needed was, first, to rediscover and reclaim his pre-Christian, Ancestral Spirituality that had previously nourished his Soul and, second, to rebuild the broken links with his Asian brothers and sisters. This was the noble task that Psychology had set itself and in so doing it offered the perfect answer to the needs of the time.

Ancient European Mythology and folklore had provided an important source of inspiration to those searching for alternative forms of Spirituality for some time. The works of Ancient Greek Philosophers were equally much-read by all knowledge-loving people. In addition to this, the European conquest of India had brought the West into contact with the vibrant Spirituality of the East on an unprecedented scale, providing a fertile soil on which the European Soul could start a new Spiritual existence.

Inspired by the great thinkers of his time and emboldened by his own researches, the Swiss Psychologist Carl Gustaf Jung (1875-1961) set about to give the Western World its Spiritual Identity back that it urgently needed in order to recover its psychological and Spiritual health and well-being. A highly intelligent and gifted man, he had long understood that the Bible was not Humanity's sole repository of Wisdom and that other Wisdom Books existed, many of which were older and perhaps wiser than the Bible itself. Not only this, but if there was any Wisdom in ancient books, might not even more Wisdom be found in the forgotten depths of man's own heart? Could not every man and woman on Earth discover their own Book of Wisdom by searching their own Souls?

Particularly popular with psychologist theorists of the time was the dubious belief that mental and emotional conditions (such as neurosis) could be solved by analysing and interpreting them in terms of the patient's history of psychosexual development - a concept chillingly reminiscent of the Church-promoted belief in Mankind's inherent sinfulness. By contrast, Jung correctly recognised that what caused psychological imbalance was the restriction or contraction of human consciousness, that is, the imposition of unnatural mental patterns - such as certain religious or scientific beliefs - upon the conscious Self or Soul. According to him, as according to Yoga, mental and emotional health and well-being could be attained only within the context of a larger Consciousness which he termed Collective Unconscious.

The concept of the Unconscious had already been known to European philosophers before Jung, and the use of dream interpretation for purposes of healing and divination had been a well-established Spiritual practice among all peoples of the Ancient World. In keeping with the time-honoured Spirituality of his Ancestors, therefore, Jung proposed to access the Collective Unconscious, that is, the Unseen (and Unknown) World of Spirit by means of certain Yoga-like techniques such as dream analysis and active imagination.

An important concept introduced by Jung was that of the Archetypes, powerful primordial images held within the Collective Unconscious and hence common to all human beings, which appeared in European folk art and mythology since times immemorial. Such Archetypes were the Wise Old Man, the Hero, the Saviour, the Sun God and many others which all corresponded to concepts found in the Yoga tradition (Adi-Natha, Maha Vira, etc.). By consciously entering the Unconscious, man could awaken and contact these Unknown Forces and utilise their creative power to transform his life. Like the great Wisemen, Shamans and Magicians of pre-Christian Europe, the more daring among Humankind could literally become the Hero, the Saviour, or the God or Goddess of their own life.

Thus the great genius of Jung consisted in the liberation of Psychology from the prison-house of clinical Psychiatry to which it had been confined by the scientific community and making it once again into the promising Spiritual endeavour it had originally been. For this reason, Jung is rightly seen as the unchallenged father of modern Western Psychology. In his inspired and gifted hands, Psychology soon became the Master Key for unlocking the Secrets of Life that would enable the Western World to fulfil its Higher Destiny in the same way as Yoga had brought Spiritual Liberation to millions in the East. This creative fusion of Ancient Spirituality and Modern Psychology was to become the driving force behind the New Age movement and lay the foundations for the World Spirituality of the New Millennium.

What must be obvious in the light of these facts, is that as already observed, Psychology in the original sense and as expounded by Professor Jung, is a natural and necessary progression from both religious belief and scientific theory. It is that field of knowledge which brings a Spiritual dimension to human existence and elevates man to higher stages of experience. Without it, Humanity would remain imprisoned in a web of mental constructs without ever seeing the life-bringing light of its own Soul.

Furthermore, as the Enlightening and Liberating Science (or Knowledge) of the Soul, true Psychology must be admitted to be essentially identical with Yoga. Indeed, both Jungian Psychology and Yoga aim to achieve a condition of Wholeness (or Unity) through Self-Realisation or Illumination which is brought about by a process of interiorisation of consciousness. By looking within, by directing the light of one's consciousness inwards, one discovers one's real Self.

It must be remembered that Western Psychology was based not only on Ancient European Spirituality (Celtic, Germanic, Greek) but also on the Yoga tradition itself which had reached Europe through translations of Ancient Indian texts inspiring an entire constellation of free-thinking Souls from the eminent philosopher Schopenhauer to the romantic writer and poet Victor Hugo and finally to Jung himself.

Although it has been generally excluded from the investigation of modern scholarship, Europe's Spiritual link with India has in fact a long history. Previous to the translation into European languages of Ancient Indian Scriptures like the Yoga Vasishta and the Upanishads (Secret Instructions) - which had first been rendered into Arabic and Persian from the Sanskrit original - a number of European travellers following both ancient and new trade routes between Europe and Asia were instrumental in the westward dissemination of Yogic teachings. The same applies to Arab and Persian Seekers - such as the Sufi Mansur-al-Halaj in the 9th century - who reportedly travelled to India with the express intention of seeking Spiritual instruction. At about the same time, Ancient Spirituality was still very much alive in many parts of Europe on which the Church forces had not yet imposed their Bible-centred ideology. It is a well-known fact that the Pagan Faith of Ancient Europe had many elements in common with the Hindu and Buddhist traditions of India. An important seat of Pagan learning was the Academy of Athens, founded by the celebrated Greek Philosopher Plato (a disciple of Socrates) in the 4th century BC and which operated without interruption until it was forced to close by the Church authorities in the 6th century CE. The members of the Academy fled to Gondeshapur, in Persia, where they established new Spiritual links with the Eastern World, in particular with India.

Following the Muslim Arab invasion of Persia, Gondeshapur and Baghdad remained important centres of learning where hundreds of Greek, Persian and Sanskrit works were translated into Arabic. Thus the Muslim ruler Kalif Mamun (813-833) founded his famous "House of Wisdom" at Baghdad for the advancement of ancient lore. The Yoga Sutra and Samkhya Sutra were translated into Arabic about 1000 CE, and Philosophy (Love of Wisdom) in general was adopted by the Islamic World as "Falsafa". These facts explain a number of peculiar developments such as the appearance of Sufism or "Tasawuf" (derived from Greek "Theosophy", "Knowledge of God" or "Divine Wisdom") as a form of Islamic mysticism.

It must be said in this context that although Yogis do not, generally speaking, leave many archaeological traces, historical evidence attests to the physical presence of "Indian sages" in the Middle East centuries before the advent of Islam. Similarly, Sanskrit inscriptions of the pre-Islamic era found in caves off the Yemeni coast indicate that Indian culture was present not only in Egypt (Alexandria) and Persia (Gondeshapur, Baghdad) as explained above, but also in the Arabian peninsula itself. We may safely infer from this that Sufism - which has many elements in common with Yoga - originally represented a form of Yoga which combined elements of Greek and Indian Philosophy to transmit its Spiritual teachings throughout the Middle East well into the Islamic age.

Unfortunately, however, religious fundamentalism was to put an end to the teaching of Philosophy and other non-Islamic, "Western sciences" and Sufism itself eventually became, for all practical purposes, just a Muslim sect. Thus, as the ancient wisdom of East and West had facilitated the rise of the Islamic World, the suppression of the same brought about its final downfall.

The question that legitimately arises at this point is, What became of the descendants of Plato's great Academy? After their initial settling in Persia, Islamic fundamentalism and Arab nationalism forced them to leave for other shores. Having entrusted representatives or deputies with the task of continuing the work in Muslim-occupied Persia, the masters and their disciples withdrew further East, to Afghanistan, Kashmir and other parts of India, where their school finally merged back into the common stream of Yogic teaching.

For a better understanding of events, it is essential to remember that prior to the advent of Christianity and Islam in the region, what is today known as "Afghanistan" and "Pakistan" formed an integral part of India, thereby making India and Persia (Iran) next-door neighbours. Moreover, these two North-West Indian provinces, together with Kashmir, were at the time highly-influential centres of Spiritual (Hindu, Buddhist and Yogic) learning. Thus, the eastward exodus precipitated by religious persecution in the West, compelled Europe's exiled men of Spirit to strengthen their traditional links with both the Ancient Mysticism of Persia and the timeless Spirituality of India, setting in motion a unique Spiritual Wave that was to feed a wide spectrum of Spiritual currents from Middle-Eastern Sufism to the European Rennaissance, continuing for many centuries to function as a great source of inspiration to Seekers of Truth throughout the Christian and Islamic Worlds. (See also Yoga and Sufism.)

Apart from the well-documented trade links between the Roman Empire and India, conclusive evidence of India's long-established Spiritual influence on Europe may be found in archaeological materials (for example, Roman inscriptions dedicated to the Indo-Persian Sun God Mithra) which suggest that Sanskrit-based mantras or mystical formulas were in use throughout the Roman Empire, that is, from Persia to Britain, up to the 3rd century CE. This fact finds further confirmation in the testimony of ancient writers (Dio Chrysostom and Clement of the first and second centuries CE) who attest the presence of Indian sages in the Egyptian city of Alexandria, a Spiritual centre of international repute in Roman times.

Indeed, the Indian Emperor Ashoka is known to have sent Buddhist monks to Greece as early as the 3rd century BC, and a century before this, Alexander the Great (after which the above-mentioned city was named) and his retinue of warriors and philosophers are reported to have maintained close contact with Yogis they had encountered during an expedition to India, being even accompanied by some of them on their return journey to Persia.

At all events, the fact is that Indian Yogis were well-known in the classical World under such names as "naked philosophers", (gymnosophists, from their custom of walking about almost or entirely naked), "forest hermits", "brahmans" and "shamans" (shramanas, in Sanskrit) as evidenced by the writings of classical writers such as Strabo and Diogenes Laertius (1st and 3rd centuries of the current era, respectively).

The teachings of Indian Yogis not only clearly influenced the leading minds of Greece and Rome but in the case of Plotinus (205-270 CE) himself, who was universally recognised as one of the wisest men of his time, they must be seen as the primary motivating factor in his decision to undertake a (unfortunately unfinished) journey to India.

Yogic teachings are found even in Early Christian writings. For example, Saint Hippolytus of Rome, writing in the 3rd century CE, tells us that, "there are some among the Indians who live a self-sufficient life, who abstain from eating living creatures and cooked food, and subsist on fruits. They say that God is Light, not like the light one sees, nor like the Sun or fire, but like the Light of Knowledge whereby the secret mysteries of Nature are perceived by the Wise" (Philosophumena XXI - The Brahmans). If Yogic teachings were known even to Roman Christians, we may reasonably expect them to have been even more prevalent in Ancient Greece. Indeed, on investigation, it becomes apparent that the equation of the Supreme Spirit with Light (the Light of Consciousness) constitutes a central element in both Yogic and Greek psycho-philosophical teachings and practices from ancient times down to the present day.

Thus, in Plato's "Symposium", it is related that his master, Socrates, would for hours stand motionless in adoration of the Sun - just as Indian Yogis and ascetics do even now. The Solar Deity, Apollo Hyperboraeus, was the God honoured by the members of the Socratic School at Athens. Now, "Apollo Hyperboraeus" or "the Sun God of the North" is just another name for the "Midnight Sun": in mythological terms, the Sun who may be seen at midnight during the summer in the northernmost regions, shines in the Other World at night when he is stationed in the North, more specifically, in the winter; while in Spiritual terms, the Northern or Midnight Sun is nothing but the Light of Consciousness which is experienced in meditation when we enter the dark inner spaces of our subconscious where everything is at first dark as in the night until the light of consciousness dawns upon us. In India, Lord Shiva, the Universal Consciousness and Supreme Principle of Yoga, has been associated with the North from earliest times. Thus He is said to reside on Mount Kailasa in the North - beyond the main Himalayan Ranges - which is the earthly reflection of Heavenly Mount Meru, the Abode of the Supreme.

Hyperboraeus, moreover, means "beyond the (northern) wind". In Spiritual terms, it signifies a supra-mental state of consciousness which lies beyond the mental processes of ordinary life which, in the manner of a blowing wind, disturb the natural peace and clarity of the human Soul. In other words, this region "beyond the northern wind" is nothing but Nirvana itself, which literally means, "No-blowing" or "No-moving", that is to say, the absolute motionelessness and calmness of the Enlightened Condition where the Supreme Light of Consciousness reigns supreme. In Ancient Greek terms, it is Hyperborea, the Blessed Land where the Sun shines day and night.

This extraordinary state of Nirvana is to be found in a higher mode of consciousness which is characterised by unobstructed Clarity and Insight symbolised by the Sun, Moon, fire or any other source of light. Meditation on the Supreme - traditionally defined as Consciousness and Bliss - in the form of light is prescribed in all Indian sacred texts from the Puranas to the Vedas and the Upanishads.

Says the Shiva Purana: "He who, with a pure mind, worships the Supreme Lord (Shiva) in the solar disc in the morning, midday and dusk, is certainly liberated" (Vayaviya Samhita II, 8:35-36). Jung himself prescribed visualisation of, and contemplation on, the sun-disc, not only for its therapeutic effect but also as a tried method of Spiritual self-realisation. Just as a burning candle is capable of lighting another candle, meditation on light stimulates and finally awakens man's dormant light of consciousness the awakening of which brings about self-realisation or direct recognition of one's own identity with Consciousness itself, the Light of all lights (Maha Prakasha). Says the Upanishad: "The Supreme Being who is in fire and in the yonder Sun is also in the heart of man". Jung similarly declares: "Whoever has in himself God, the Sun, is immortal, like the Sun".

Although this Spiritual dimension is often denied in modern academic circles which seek to present psychology and philosophy as a purely intellectual enterprise, it becomes clear that the Light of Consciousness as a darkness or ignorance dispelling Spiritual force is the Supreme Principle which Western psychology and philosophy have shared with the Eastern tradition of Yoga from the very beginning. Indeed, the sacred geography, Spiritual symbolism and emphasis on Self-knowledge ("Know thyself" was the maxim inscribed above the entrance to the Oracle of Apollo at Delphi) shared by both the Socratic school of Greece and the Yogic tradition of India, clearly indicate a basic identity between the two traditions.

Going further back in time, the Orphic Traditions (so-called Mystery Religions) of Ancient Greece and Thrace (8th-9th centuries BC) - on which later philosophical schools like that of Socrates were based - had sufficient elements in common with the teachings of Yoga (Reincarnation, the Wheel of Rebirth, Vegetarianism) to render them essentially identical with the latter, in particular, if we consider that "Yoga" in its original sense meant "Spiritual Discipline", as opposed to the "System of physical postures" for which it is taken by many today. A similar relation of identity may be found between the European and Indian systems of Astrology which, in their original form, had a magical, religious and Spiritual significance. Finally, we must not forget that European languages themselves were closely related to Sanskrit, the classical language of India, which for millennia has functioned as the linguistic medium for the transmission of Yogic teaching.

In short, there can be no doubt that numerous channels of Spiritual communication between East and West have been in operation - as they still are - since prehistoric times. Humans are, after all, communicative beings. In any event, that modern Spirituality has been greatly influenced, inspired and stimulated by Yogic thought can hardly be a matter of debate nor can modern Psychology, as a Spiritual endeavour, logically be assumed to have remained outside the Yogic sphere of influence. The fact is that Yogic teaching has not only provided the foundation for modern Western Spirituality (including Psychology) but has also brought profound changes to Science itself.

A few instances of this will no doubt suffice to illustrate the point. Charles Darwin's theory of evolution is, for all practical purposes, merely a materialist form of the Yogic teaching concerning the evolution of the individual atom of consciousness that gradually evolves through mineral, vegetal and animal life to human, superhuman and finally Divine, modes of existence. Being initially adopted by the scientific community as a non-religious alternative to the biblical Creation Myth, Darwin's findings are now more correctly seen by many scientists and theologians as describing the biological aspect of what constitutes an essentially Spiritual process. Yoga, of course, fully agrees with the concept of life as an evolutionary process, yet it insists that this process is governed by a Higher, Spiritual Principle or Force.

If the doubt should arise here as to how precisely had a British scholar of the 19th century come to be in possession of Yogic knowledge, the answer is very simple. Being contemporaneous with such remarkable students of Eastern Spirituality as the German philosopher Arthur Schopenhauer (1788-1860) and the French poet and writer Victor Hugo (1802-1885), and having taken an interest in religion before turning to natural history, Darwin (1809-1882) must have come across the same, or similar, Yogic material as inspired other European luminaries of his time. In fact, as a British subject with an interest in religion he could scarcely have avoided coming into contact with the Spirituality of India, a country that at the time was in every respect a very important part of the British Empire.

Nor must one suppose that the theory of evolution was in any way an exclusive monopoly of Darwin. The less famous British naturalist Alfred Russel Wallace and the Dutch anatomist Eugene Dubois, among others, had come to much the same scientific conclusions as Darwin himself. Interestingly, they were both taken by their researches to the East Indies. Now, without wishing to stretch the point, it seems rather difficult to dismiss as a matter of coincidence the fact that three different European men should have developed the same notion of Creation as an evolutionary process, simultaneously and independently of one another at precisely that point in European history when Yogic ideas were becoming accessible to the Western mind on an unprecedented scale.

Indeed, much as Indian culture and Spirituality had deeply influenced the whole of East Asia including China and Japan, the immense impact of Indian Wisdom on the Western World was such that by the 19th century many facets of it had become common knowledge among the educated classes from Russia (see Helena P. Blavatsky, 1831-1891) to Britain (Annie Besant, 1847-1933), illumining even such supposedly remote and backward corners of Europe as Romania where, in the second half of the century, the romantic poet Michael Eminescu (1850-1889) would be moved to compose verses to Kamadeva, the Hindu God of Love (who is universally revered in India as a manifestation of Lord Shiva).

One only needs to think of the Anthroposophist movement, for instance, a world-wide Spiritual initiative founded by the Austrian philosopher and scientist, Rudolf Steiner (1861-1925), that is known to have absorbed a wide range of Eastern ideas and practices including meditation. After all, if Yogic terms like "Atman", "Nirvana", "Reincarnation" and "Yoga" have long become assimilated into Western languages, we may safely conjecture that the teachings and practices they describe cannot have been far behind, as evidenced by the following statement: "Clear knowledge of spirit arises from Yoga, or abstraction of Nirvana" (W. Ward 1820). Nor can scientists, in so far as they belong to the human species, be supposed to be entirely isolated from, or immune to, cross-cultural influences.

We can now easily understand how timeless Yogic teachings such as those based upon the concept of a Universal Energy as the underlying substratum of the material World could have passed into the teachings of modern Physics. We can also see how, in the field of modern Medicine, a rising number of Western practitioners are professionally recognising the prophylactic and therapeutic properties of Yogic techniques while many of them are personally taking up the practice of Yoga. It is an established fact that most complementary and alternative techniques of diagnosis and therapy in use today, for example, Reiki (or energy-healing) are ultimately based on the teachings of Yoga, having reached the West via Tibet and the Far East. The therapeutic use of Meditation, Chanting, Spiritual Music, Aromatherapy and a whole range of other techniques extensively employed in alternative Medicine today, have been equally known to the Yogis of India for millennia. This, of course, is only natural if we consider that as the Science of Unity, Yoga logically includes the Science of Wholeness or Health. (We may note in this context that Shiva, the God of Yoga has been regarded as the Supreme Physician since prehistoric times.)

In the light of this, our contention to the effect that Western Psychology is ultimately based upon, and originated in, the teachings of Yoga, is neither surprising nor can be reasonably denied. It can hardly be mere coincidence that European words denoting consciousness are practically direct translations of the Yogic term Samvid - the Swedish word Samvete being even phonetically identical with the Sanskrit original - and that other key psychological terms likewise find their equivalents in Yogic vocabulary: ego (aham), id (idam), etc. Even psychoanalitical terms like "Nirvana-principle", notwithstanding their negative connotations, demonstrate a clear link to Yogic teachings.

In Jung's own words: "On account of the remarkable agreement between the insights of Yoga and the results of psychological research, I have chosen the Sanskrit term 'mandala' for this central symbol [of the centre, or essence, of the collective unconscious]" (The Psychology of Eastern Meditation, 1943).

Of course, in his talks and writings, Jung could only express this fact in an indirect way. One had to be careful when talking about things that challenged the consensus ideology of the time. Indeed, the situation was such that until well into the second half of the 20th century, Spiritual Seekers wishing to break free from the stranglehold of official dogma were often forced to meet in secret and lived in fear of being discovered by the authorities. The State-sponsored arrogance and intolerance towards non-Biblical culture and Spirituality is perhaps best epitomised in the infamous utterance of a British Prime Minister, Winston Churchill: "I hate Indians. They are a beastly people with a beastly religion." And this in spite of the fact that thousands of Indians lost their lives defending the Empire's interests in many parts of the World.

Evidently, this irrational, offensive and almost pathological hostility towards non-Biblical forms of Spirituality was systematically fostered by the political Establishment of Europe as a tool for maintaining power over its own people as well as keeping the colonised nations under control. Unconditional obedience to Church and State had to be enforced by any means. It will be not out of place to observe here that according to the Declaration Dominus Iesus, recently issued by the Vatican (5th Sept. 2000), non-Christian religions represent "an obstacle to salvation". This confirms the wide-spread concern that, even today, far from seeking to redress past errors, leading figures within the Christian community continue to cultivate an irresponsible attitude of unexamined prejudice against non-Biblical traditions.

Even so, Jung whose teachings had already reached Britain and America, was bold enough to affirm that Western Psychology and the string of techniques that had arisen from it, was the effort of mere beginners when compared to the state-of-the-art Spirituality of the East. In his essay, Yoga and the West, Jung explains that Yoga aims to achieve nothing less than the liberation of consciousness from the limitations of objects and ideas. In doing so, he implicitly (and correctly) equates his own system of Analytical Psychology or Psychosynthesis (Self-Unity) to Yoga - which shared the same Spiritual Ideal with the teachings of the Ancient European Masters (Plato, Plotinus, etc) - as opposed to mainstream Psychology which remained the prisoner of its own biased and, therefore, unscientific materialism.

Jung unequivocally made his position clear by stating that Yoga offered undreamt-of possibilities. Indeed, Yoga offers everything already given by both Religion and Science to which it adds the benefit of Higher Experience and the prospect of freedom, power and happiness in this very lifetime. In view of the public attitude towards "alien faiths" that was prevalent in Jung's time, it would be unreasonable to expect him to have expressed his views any more clearly than he did. Needless to say, had he done so, it would have amounted to professional suicide. Jung was, after all, a Psychiatrist by profession and although many regarded him as a Spiritual leader, his main concern was to wean his colleagues away from their sterile and often anti-Spiritual approach to the treatment of psychological conditions.

Jung's dilemma was that while he was - in true Yogic fashion - fully aware of the fact that one could not properly practise Psychiatry (Soul-Healing) without true Psychology (Soul-Knowledge), society was still not ready to accept his insights into the exact nature of genuine Psychology which, as we have seen, was essentially identical with Yoga. In consequence, Jung had to put his teachings across as gently and cautiously as possible, often even in coded language, so as not to offend the political, religious or scientific sensitivities of his audience. Nor should this surprise us as to a large extent we are obliged to do the same even today. As we are entering the New Millennium, we find ourselves living in a society that is still very much in the grip of political, religious or scientific dogma. Freedom of Consciousness and Freedom of Expression remain a rare and most precious possession that continues to be threatened by ignorance and intolerance in many parts of the World including the West.

Conclusion

From what has gone before, the whole issue may be summed up as follows: Psychologically speaking, Yoga is a process leading to Self-Awareness, Self-Knowledge or Self-Unity, that is, a mode of experience in which consciousness has a direct perception of itself and operates in unity, or at one, with itself, thereby creating a unique condition of wholeness, health and happiness. All religious, scientific or Spiritual teaching or activity, including certain forms of Western Psychology, is logically identical with Yoga when, and to the extent to which, it produces the same results.

In historical terms, Western Psychology, in particular its Jungian branch, has been stimulated, inspired and influenced by Yoga and has in turn prepared the ground for the understanding and acceptance of Yoga on a large scale in Western Society. Indeed, Jung's Analytical Psychology may be said to be the only modern Western system of thought through which Yoga can be properly understood. (As far as Ancient European traditions are concerned, those of the Druids and pre-Christian Gnostics may fulfil a similar function.) From a Spiritual viewpoint, therefore, which includes both the psychological and historical dimensions of the issue, the true function of Western Psychology has consisted in removing the culture-specific psychological sediments that were blocking the channels of East-West Spiritual communication so that the World-Liberating Yogic Truth of Universal Unity may reach the heart of all people. Today, this Spiritual Process is carried forward and expanded through the worldwide activities of The Yoga Order and the teaching entities associated with it.

In the context of practical application it may suffice to here observe that Yoga Psychology has many points of resemblance with not only the teachings of Carl G. Jung - in particular active imagination - but also what is known as Transpersonal Psychology and Cognitive Behaviour Therapy. What is essential to understand in all circumstances is that the aim of Yogic teachings and practices is primarily Spiritual in nature.

For further information on Yoga Psychology see also the following:

- Momentariness
- The thirty-six Realities (Tattvas) of Yoga
- Obstacles on the Yoga Path
- Meditation

 

<<  Yoga Council Home          Questions & Answers >>