YOUR QUESTIONS ANSWERED: F.A.Q. 5

 

 

 

ORIGIN OF YOGA

QUESTION: What is the historical basis for the attribution of the origins of Yoga to Shiva? It has been remarked by some scholars that the Yoga Sutra, one of the earliest works on Yoga, only briefly introduces the concept of God who is moreover not mentioned by name.

ANSWER: Just as the Sun always and already shines regardless of whether people's vision of him is obscured by clouds, darkness or blindness, so also, Yoga - which is the Luminous Expression of the Supreme Consciousness, constantly fills the Universe with its Eternal Light of Truth. Yet because ordinary humans and other un-Enlightened beings are unaware of the Light of Truth - much as a blind man is unaware of the light of the Sun - it remains "underground", buried, as it were, in the innermost recesses of un-Enlightened man's subconscious. This being so, it is the task of a Yoga Master (who is a Master of Spiritual Illumination) to bring this living light to the surface so that they, to whom it belongs, may see it face to face and recognise it as their own true essence.

Authentic Yogic Teaching is a living tradition based on the higher experience of living Masters and its direct transmission to their disciples. Written texts, valuable though they may be, are - by their very nature - more limited in their capacity to transmit Spiritual knowledge, than a living tradition. Even so, confusion regarding the identity of Lord Shiva as World Teacher and Originator of Yoga can only arise if and when: (a) the living tradition is improperly investigated or altogether ignored; (b) scriptural tradition, or isolated fragments of it such as the Yoga Sutra, are examined outside their proper cultural, historical and Spiritual context. A clearer picture emerges when we adopt the Yogic view of reality which is deeper, more complete and, therefore, closer to truth. As the Scriptures say, Yoga can only be known by means of Yoga.

First, the Yoga Sutra, which has been dated to about 180 BC - although it is generally accepted that it contains material going back far before that - is a very concise work dealing mainly with the psycho-philosophical interpretation of Yogic teachings and does not constitute a religious work as such. Second, it contradicts neither the existence of God nor the identity of that God with Shiva. Third, in the Yoga Tradition, out of pious respect and in recognition of Its Inexpressible Nature, the Supreme Being is not given a name but is indirectly referred to by means of some symbolic designation such as "Lord" (Ish, Ishvara), "Master" (Natha), "The Most High" (Anuttara) or simply "He" (Sah). "Shiva" itself is not a proper name like that given to an individual person but a technical term expressing the concept of God, that is, the Universal Being Who - in the experience of Yogis - has the power to help us in our Spiritual effort, hence Shiva (Auspicious, Propitious, Good, Gracious).

This Universal Being is referred to by the author of the Yoga Sutra, Patanjali, simply as Ishvara (Lord, God). However, the fact is that Ishvara - along with Maheshvara (Great Lord) and Parameshvara (Supreme Lord) - is a term commonly used by Shiva's devotees when referring to their God, a fact long recognised by the eminent Dr. Surendranath Dasgupta, Ph.D., in his "History of Indian Philosophy" (1922).

In consequence, we cannot reasonably exclude the possibility that the term "Ishvara" was employed in the same sense by Patanjali himself. Indeed, we may safely assume that this was the case. Moreover, Patanjali does state that Ishvara (God) is Eternal, he exists beyond time, and as such he is the Primordial Guru (Adi-Guru) of the Ancient Sages. Not only is this in agreement with the Yogic concept of Lord Shiva, but from a number of reliable sources we happen to know exactly who this Primordial Guru is.

In its overview of the history of Indian religion, the Encyclopedia Britannica states that, "the cult of Shiva emerged first. Shiva alone was called Isha or Ishvara (Lord, God)". Professor M. Eliade's Encyclopedia of Religion states that "In classical Hindu mythology Shiva is generally portrayed as a Yogi who lives on Mount Kailasa in the Himalayas [that is, in Heaven]". While epithets such as Yoga-Isha (Yogesha) and Yoganatha, meaning "Lord of Yoga", are explained as "Names of Shiva" in the Monier-Williams Sanskrit-English Dictionary. Thus Ishvara's equation with Shiva as Lord of Yoga is common knowledge even in the West at least among the educated classes.

We shall now hear the testimony of the Indian tradition itself. The renowned Yoga Teacher, B. K. S. Iyengar, begins his book, "The Light on Yoga" with the following prayer: "I salute Adishvara (Primeval Lord Shiva) who taught first the science of Hatha Yoga". The great sage of South India, Shri Ramana Maharshi (1879-1950), referred in his teachings to Lord Shiva as Lord of Yoga (Yogaraja) and Primal Master (Adi-Guru, Dakshinamurti, etc.).

The Collection Of Shiva's Sayings (Shiva Samhita), a Yoga manual compiled in about 1700, begins with the words: "I, Ishvara (that is, Lord Shiva), Lover of my devotees and Bestower of Spiritual Freedom on all beings, thus declare the Science of Yoga." The Song Of The Lord (Ishvara Gita of the Kurma Purana), likewise portrays Shiva as the World Teacher Who instructs a group of sages.

In his main work, The Light of the Sacred Scriptures (Tantraloka) Illustrious Master Mahamaheshvara Abhinava Gupta, one of India's most eminent Spiritual authorities (c. 950-1025) belonging to the North Indian Tradition of Shiva, unequivocally acknowledges Shiva as Supreme Lord and Primordial Guru. The South Indian Saint and Philosopher, Shri Shankaracharya (c. 800), who was one of the most influencial figures in the history of Indian religion and philosophy, similarly eulogises Lord Shiva as the Supreme Eternal Guru (see Dakshinamurti Stotram, Shivanandalahari, etc.).

In the Natha tradition of the first centuries of the current era and the earlier (about 100 BC), Pashupata tradition, the Primal Lord (Adi-Natha) is likewise identified with Lord Shiva Who is the Eternal Divine Teacher.

A very important Yogic text from about the same period as the Yoga Sutra - if not earlier - is The Revelation Of The Tremendous Wisdom God (Vijnana Bhairava Tantra) also known as The Secret Instruction In The Wisdom Of Shiva (Shiva Vijnana Upanishad), in which Supreme Lord Shiva (Parameshvara) in His Tremendous (Bhairava), Darkness-Dispelling Aspect acts as Divine World Teacher.

One of India's oldest Spiritual traditions, that of the Jains, which goes back at least 3,000 years, similarly venerates Adi-Natha as the First Guru. Now since this Guru's symbolic emblem is a Bull, this clearly identifies him with Shiva who has always been associated with the Bull on account of the latter's immemorial symbolism of sheer strength, rain-making abilities and generative power (both "bull" and "rain" in Sanskrit are derived from the root "Vrish", to rain as well as to have manly power).

Indeed, Shiva's symbol has been the Bull (Nandi, Bestower of Bliss) at least from the times of the Indus Valley civilisation. In the hymns of the Rig Veda, Shiva in His aspect of Rudra is addressed by the title of "Bull". Another great Teacher and religious reformer of the Jain tradition is known by the name of Mahavira (Great Hero) - another epithet of Shiva ("Lord of Heroes" is one of Shiva's titles already mentioned in the Vedas).

Indeed, the Hindu Wisdom-Book of Hymns (Rig Veda), dating from the 4th millennium BC, mentions the God of Mystic Fire (Rudra) who is as bright as the Sun and has healing powers: "We pray for joy and health and strength to Rudra, Lord of sacrifice and hymns and balmy medicines. He shines in splendour like the Sun, refulgent as bright gold is He, the Good, the best among the Gods!" (Ralph T.H. Griffith's translation). Now to heal means to re-unite and make whole, that is to say, precisely the power and function of Shiva in His capacity as Lord of Yoga or Unity. Rudra, of course, remains one of Lord Shiva's sacred names even today.

Moreover, later commentaries on the Wisdom-Books (Vedas) refer to this Luminous Deity as Vratya-Pati, that is, Lord of Ascetics which is another long-established epithet of Shiva. Indeed, since prehistoric times the Sunlike God of Inner Fire has been universally identified with Shiva, the Lord of Yogis and Ascetics and Supreme Healer. Later Scriptures like Shvetashvatara Upanishad (6th century BC) clearly continue this timeless tradition.

Echoes of this tradition may be found in the Great Epic of India, Mahabharata, where the ancient Vedic term Vratya is used in association with certain followers of Shiva. Moreover, in the Mahabharata Lord Shiva plays a central role, in particular, as Spiritual Teacher. Thus that portion of the epic known as Harivamsha Purana, names Sage Durvasas (an Incarnation or Manifestation of Shiva) as Lord Krishna's Spiritual Instructor. Finally, the Mahabharata concludes that "Shiva is Yoga and the Lord of Yoga. He can be approached by Yogis only".

Even the Buddhist tradition acknowledges Lord Shiva as Master of Yoga. Thus according to the Monier-Williams Sanskrit-English Dictionary, "Maha-Yogin" or "Supreme Yogi" is a "name of Shiva especially when worshipped by Buddhists".

The fact is that an immense scriptural body based on the same fundamental tradition of Shiva as Lord of Yoga has been in circulation for at least as long as the Yoga Sutra and its very existence demonstrates that in most Yoga circles there has never been any doubt regarding the precise identity of the Original Teacher. Although the teachings and practices of Yoga - or aspects thereof - have long been adopted by a number of Yogic and non-Yogic traditions including Buddhism, Christianity and Islam, to this day the vast majority of Yogis continue to follow the Tradition of Shiva (Shiva Agama or Shiva Dharma).

Indeed, as evidenced by countless works of devotional art - both ancient and modern - Shiva is worshipped throughout India as the supreme example of the Archetypal Teacher (Jagad-Guru, World Teacher) per se, not only of Yoga, Enlightenment or Spirituality, but also of innumerable arts and crafts: dance, music, poetry, healing, love (both Spiritual and physical), magic, archery and hunting.

On the whole, therefore, it may be said that, apart from the living tradition itself, there is sufficient scriptural and circumstantial evidence for Shiva's identity as Originator of Yoga to be accepted as conclusively established.

Says Scripture: "In every World Age, Lord Shiva incarnates as Teacher of Yoga (Yogacharya) and propagates its wisdom for the Salvation of His devotees" (Shiva Purana, Vayaviya Samhita I, 32:14; II, 8:43, etc.).

We have thus demonstrated that, while the Yoga Sutra constitutes a valuable introduction to Yogic teachings, the higher truths of Yoga are to be found in the Tradition of Shiva (Shiva Agama) itself which is the true origin of Yoga.

Nevertheless, the cultural and historical factors so far considered can only be of secondary importance belonging as they do to the external domain of conventional knowledge. If we enter the real World of Yoga which is the World of Higher (Inner) Knowledge, we may acquire an even deeper and more accurate understanding of the situation.

First, there are three fundamental forms of Spiritual Revelation or Transmission of Higher Intelligence, which Yoga identifies as accounting for the great diversity of religious and Spiritual traditions in the World:

1. Revelations that are entirely the product, conscious or subconscious, of the individual mind and hence do not count as genuine, properly speaking.

2. Revelations that are genuine transmissions of the Universal Mind but are misinterpreted or misunderstood by the recipient individual or group of individuals.

3. Revelations that are both genuine transmissions of the Universal Mind and are correctly interpreted and understood as such by the recipient individual (or group of individuals).

Although on the relative level they appear to derive from different spatial and temporal points of origin, at the level of non-dual, Unitive Awareness of Yogic Consciousness, all currents of genuine Spiritual Instruction are recognised as emanating from the same Source Intelligence.

In other words, only One Teaching Entity or Guiding Principle (Guru Tattva) is ultimately responsible for all teaching activity.

Not only this, but since all forms of intelligence are generated by, and have their existence in, the same Universal Consciousness, both the Transmitter and recipient of Spiritual Intelligence (or "Teacher" and "learner") are essentially identical as conscious projections of the same One Universal Intelligence. Yoga being, by definition, the Spirituality of absolute non-duality (Advaita) or Unity, this is the only Spiritually true and logically acceptable position.

This Spiritual fact is accurately described in The Revelation Of The Tremendous Freedom God (Svachchanda Bhairava Tantra), compiled in the 5th century CE, which declares: Eternal Lord Shiva (Sada Shiva), God Incarnate, manifests Himself as both Master and disciple for the purpose of bringing to the World the Revelation of Truth in the form of questions and answers.

In other words, Shiva, the Supreme Self instructs the individual self (the human Soul) who is His Own Manifestation into the Yogic Truth of Universal Unity. "In the beginning", says Scripture, "this Universe was Atman (Spirit, Soul) alone; looking around, he saw nothing but Himself." Thus the Lord instructs those whom He wishes to elevate, into the Eternal Truth of the Soul's identity with the Supreme.

The Supreme Instructor (Parama Guru) is one's own Higher Self, the Divine Light shining in one's own heart. For this reason, Scripture declares, "One should worship the Self alone as his true World. Whosoever worships another God (than his own Higher Self), thinking, He is one and I another, knows not. He is like a sacrificial animal for the Gods."

Identity of the human Soul with the Supreme (Shiva-Samata) is the Secret of Yoga, of true Spirituality and of all genuine Faiths.

This also solves another problem that is sometimes raised in this context: how can Shiva or Ishvara, as a Transcendental Intelligence existing outside relative reality, instruct a human being who lives in a world governed by the laws of time and space? The answer is simple enough. Since everything is created by, and has its existence within, the all-inclusive Universal Consciousness, all genuine Spiritual Revelation necessarily takes place on the impulse and through the medium of that very Consciousness Itself.

Indian folklore actually looks upon Patanjali as an Incarnation of Ananta, a Serpent-like Divine Being. Now according to an ancient tradition, Ananta is the name given to an Emanation of Shiva. "Ananta, King of Serpents, is Shiva" - says the Shiva Purana (Vayaviya Samhita, II, 4:47).

In Yogic terms, this means that Ananta is the Serpent-like Stream of Spiritual Intelligence that emerges from the deeps of the Infinite Ocean of Consciousness in order to communicate to us a Higher and previously hidden (or unrecognised) Knowledge, and that Patanjali himself wrote the Yoga Sutra under the inspiration of Ananta, the Emanation of Shiva's Universal Intelligence.

By the same mechanism, the authors of the Vijnana Bhairava Tantra, Ishvara Gita and the rest, composed their respective works which together constitute the many facets of the Infinite Jewel of Yogic Wisdom. This fact is further supported by Shiva's traditional epithet of Nagesha-Natha or Lord of Serpents: as the Universal Consciousness, Shiva is both the Source and Master of all conscious activity, and hence of all Streams of Spiritual Intelligence issuing, serpent-like, that is, with a wave-like movement suggesting vibration or pulsation, from the Ocean of Ultimate Reality.

In terms of Western Psychology - as expounded by Professor Jung - this universal phenomenon may be similarly interpreted as a function of the Collective Unconscious which, in this case, is nothing but the Universal Consciousness (Para-Samvid) of Yogic Psychology, called "Unconscious" because it is largely unconscious or unknown to the Spiritually unaware personal mind.

It might be noted in passing that this concept of a Divine Serpent as mediator of Higher Knowledge is of the greatest anthropological, psychological and Spiritual interest. Thus we find a Celestial Dragon among the Chinese and a Plumed Serpent among the Ancient Mexicans along with the Uraeus Snake of the Egyptian Pharaohs, the Divine Python of the Greeks, the Serpent Lord of the Tree of Truth of Ancient Sumer and last but not least, the Serpent Power (Kundalini Shakti) of Yoga itself, all of which are but various symbolic representations of essentially the same Divine Entity embodying Spiritual Knowledge, Wisdom, or Truth.

Says Scripture: "When everything was neither existent nor non-existent, when it was neither day nor night, Shiva alone existed. From Him the Ancient Wisdom emanated" (Vayaviya Samhita I, 6:39).

Nor must one assume that the Yogis' choice of the term Shiva as a designation for the all-inclusive Universal Intelligence is in any way sectarian, dogmatic or even arbitrary. This important point has been graciously elucidated by the Master of The Yoga Order, Gurudev Shri Soma-Natha Maharaj as follows: the essence of all life is conscious activity (or awareness and movement); life is also essentially good. Indeed, the Sanskrit word Shiva means, first of all, good, benevolent, auspicious. Second, it may be broken down into the phonemes or sound units, Shi and Va. Shi (literally, that in which all things lie or rest - from the root "shi", lie, come to rest, reside in) means to support, include, embrace, contain, while Va suggests movement. In consequence, Shiva designates the All-Including, All-Supporting Living Intelligence Which encompasses or contains everything within Its field of awareness (and therefore knows everything) and by Whose power everything moves. In short, the Supreme Reality Itself.

In our experience, it is a Spiritual fact that all genuine Seekers will sooner or later accept the Universal Consciousness (or World Spirit) as the Original Source of all Spiritual teaching or activity, including Yoga, and it matters little what we choose to call this Source. Thus, Vishnu, Buddha, Yahweh, Allah, Universal Being, Ultimate Reality or any other corresponding designations, must be regarded as equally valid if and to the extent that they are capable of evoking in the Seeker's heart a meaning equivalent, or sufficiently similar to the aforementioned and provided that they are conducive to an understanding among the individuals concerned, of the fact that they all are seeking the same One Truth. (It may be noteworthy that this has enabled people of Spirit all over the World - Hindus, Buddhists, Christians, Muslims, Pagans and Jews - to recognise the value of Yoga as an inner Spiritual process regardless of their external or official religious allegiance.) The term Shiva has been chosen by us in preference to others first because it constitutes a most apt appellation for the Universal Intelligence or Godhead - as defined above - and second because it is supported by the Yoga Tradition itself.

In the light of these considerations, the Initiation of the Spiritual Process, called Yoga, by Lord Shiva (the Universal Consciousness) must be admitted to be - both Spiritually and historically speaking - a factual occurrence that no one can logically deny.

However, this must not lead us to lose sight of another fact, namely, that Yoga is not only the Spiritual process whereby the human Soul may re-unite himself with the Universal Being from Whom he has become separated, but also the Universal Unity itself, that is, the Unitive Experience the Universal Being has of Himself as a Unique Undivided Reality.

This Experience of Absolute Unity with Himself which is the Supreme Being's very nature (or natural state) is the highest form of Unity or Yoga.

As such, Yoga has always existed and continues to constitute an Eternal Reality above and beyond the spatial and temporal domain of the material World (see Yoga - The World's Oldest Faith).

 

<<  Yoga Council Home          Questions & Answers >>